www.xlr8yourmac.com
The Source for Mac Performance News and Reviews

Systems  | CPU Upgrades  | SCSI | IDE | Firewire  | Video  | Audio  | Games  | Misc/OS  | Archives  | Search

Searchable Databases of Mac Owner Reports on:
CPU Upgrades | Drive Compatibility (HD/DVD/CDRW/Tape) | System/Graphics Benchmarks | Game Reviews

Got Questions? - Check the FAQ for Answers
800+ Answers on CPU Upgrades/CDR/DVD/Storage/Video Cards/Firewire/Games & More!
Email News/Tips/Reviews | Advertise here
Return to News Page

Click for Mercury Elite FW/USB Drives!
Click for Mercury Elite FW/USB Drives!

After Effects CS3 Public Preview vs. After Effects v7 Performance
(Mac Pro and G5 Towers)

Last Updated: 5/23/2007



"I just downloaded the Adobe After Effects CS3 Public Preview updated version and was able to run some tests, let me tell you this is FAST!

My test machines:
Mac Pro 2.66GHz
2GB RAM
After Effects 7
After Effects CS3 preview 8.0.0.283

Power Mac G5 2GHz Dual Processor
4GB RAM
After Effects 7
After Effects CS3 preview 8.0.0.283 (only recognizes 3GB of RAM)

Test file:
1:30 DVCPROHD 1080i 60fps
KeyLight 1.2v5 (received Universal Binary version from The Foundry)
Auto Color correction

Times to Complete:
G5 Dual 2GHz, AE7 = 1hr 52min
G5 Dual 2GHz, CS3 = 1hr 47min

Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE7 = 1hr 10min
Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE CS3 = 20min

As you can see from before the Mac Pro is faster in AE7 even running under rosetta, as we already knew, but the Mac Pro completely stomps the G5 with the new CS3 build. Thanks for the great site!
(he later wrote)
Add these times:

Test File:
1:10 DVCPROHD 720p 30fps:

  • G5 Dual 2GHz, AE CS3 = 18min
  • Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE CS3 = 5min

    Can't do an AE7 test on this one because I started the project in CS3.

    -Donald"


  • "Hey there, I saw Donald's post earlier and downloaded the AE CS3 preview to test it out too. I just ran the old Nightflight Render on a Mac Pro and a G5 and saw an immediate improvement in both systems.
    However, I didn't get nearly the same stomping performance from the Intel. Maybe its because of the plug-ins. Go figure. In my experience, I get wildly different results depending on plug-ins sometimes. The main reason I hang onto the G5 is that Color Finesse seems to love it. Anyways...

    (Nightflight Render)

  • Mac Pro 2.66GHz (4 GB RAM) - 69 sec in AE-CS3, 154 sec in AE-7
  • G5 2.5GHz Quad (4GB RAM) - 78 sec in AE-CS3, 155 sec in AE-7

    Multiprocessing was enabled on both systems, so there was a big improvement as far as Nightflight goes. Not surprisingly, the universal code of CS3 definitely improves Intel performance more than it helps the G5 though! But like I said. I didn't the monster difference that Donald got, especially if one takes the faster clock speed of the Intel system into account. Maybe if I had an Octo-Core Mac Pro, the G5 might have gotten trounced.
    James"

  • Donald also had a 2.66GHz Mac Pro (2GB of RAM) but his (4GB RAM) G5 was only a Dual 2GHz model (not a 2.5GHz Quad like yours) - plus he used different (much larger/longer) test files - note his times to complete were much longer.





    Wireless Adapters


    OWC SPECIALS!
    (see full list)

    = MEMORY =
    4GB (2x2GB) Mac Pro RAM (800MHz) $111.50

    4GB (2x2GB) Mac Pro RAM (667MHz) $106

    4GB (2x2GB) PC6400 for 2008 iMacs $58.75

    4GB (2x2GB) PC2-5300 SODIMMs $57.50

    2GB PC2-5300 SODIMM $29.75

    1GB DDR400 DIMMs $28.25

    512MB PC-133 SDRAM $30.75

    = WIRELESS =
    802.11N/g/b PCI, PCMCIA or USB adapters under $50
    802.11N/G/B Router $65

    = TV TUNERS/DVR =
    ElGato Turbo.264 (RFB) $57.50

    EyeTV 250+ w/clear QAM $130

    = CPU UPGRADES =
    7448 2.0GHz $375

    7447A 1.6GHz $225

    G3 1GHz ZIF upgrade $99.75

    = HARD DRIVES =
    500GB 7200rpm/16MB cache $69

    WD 640GB 7200rpm/16MB Cache $74.75

    1TB SATA HDs from $115

    1.5TB Seagate HD $175

    EliteAL eSATA/FW800/400/USB 2.0 Case Kit w/SW $75

    1TB EliteAL FW/USB 2.0 $190

    1TB EliteAL SATA/FW800/400/USB2 $227.50

    = NOTEBOOK HDs =
    500GB Samsung M6 HD + USB 2.0 Case Kit $175

    250GB 7200rpm Notebook HD + USB 2.0 Case kit $112.75

    320GB/7200RPM/16MB cache $107.50

    200GB/7200RPM/16MB cache $72.50

    = GRAPHICS CARDS =
    ATI HD 3870 PCIe $217.99

    ATI 9800 Pro AGP $205

    ATI 9600 Mac/PC AGP $179

    = SOFTWARE =
    Prosoft Data Rescue II $57.50

    Mac Office 2008 $225

    XLR8YourMac.com T-Shirts $14.99
    Support this site!


    = Buy this Website! =
    Make an Offer
    Millions of page views/mo.
    Huge potential!

    FasterMac.net
    Internet Access


    Mac Help Now!
    Freq. Asked Questions
    (Check First!)

    Mac Model Articles

    CPU Upgrade Articles

    Video/Card Articles

    Storage Articles

    Search Mac Drive Upgrades/Compat. Database

    Search the CPU Upgrade Database

    Search the
    Game/System Perf. Database

    Read Game Reviews


    Recent Reviews and Articles:
    Listing/links to recent articles, guides and reviews you may have missed.  Details

     
    = back to www.XLR8YOURMAC.com =


    = Other Site Topic Areas =
    Systems | CPU Upgrades | SCSI | IDE | Video | Firewire | Audio | Tips/Misc | Mac OS Articles | FAQ


    Copyright © , 1997-2008. All Rights Reserved
    All brand or product names mentioned here are properties of their respective companies.

    Legal: Users of the web site must read and are bound by the terms and conditions of use.