After Effects CS3 Public Preview vs. After Effects v7 Performance
(Mac Pro and G5 Towers)
Last Updated: 5/23/2007
"I just downloaded the Adobe After Effects CS3 Public Preview updated version
and was able to run some tests, let me tell you this is FAST!
My test machines:
Mac Pro 2.66GHz
2GB RAM
After Effects 7
After Effects CS3 preview 8.0.0.283
Power Mac G5 2GHz Dual Processor
4GB RAM
After Effects 7
After Effects CS3 preview 8.0.0.283 (only recognizes 3GB of RAM)
Test file:
1:30 DVCPROHD 1080i 60fps
KeyLight 1.2v5 (received Universal Binary version from The Foundry)
Auto Color correction
Times to Complete:
G5 Dual 2GHz, AE7 = 1hr 52min
G5 Dual 2GHz, CS3 = 1hr 47min
Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE7 = 1hr 10min
Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE CS3 = 20min
As you can see from before the Mac Pro is faster in AE7 even running under
rosetta, as we already knew, but the Mac Pro completely stomps the G5 with
the new CS3 build. Thanks for the great site!
(he later wrote)
Add these times:
Test File:
1:10 DVCPROHD 720p 30fps:
G5 Dual 2GHz, AE CS3 = 18min
Mac Pro 2.66GHz, AE CS3 = 5min
Can't do an AE7 test on this one because I started the project in CS3.
-Donald"
"Hey there, I saw Donald's post earlier and downloaded the AE CS3
preview to test it out too. I just ran the old Nightflight Render on
a Mac Pro and a G5 and saw an immediate improvement in both systems.
However, I didn't get nearly the same stomping performance from the
Intel. Maybe its because of the plug-ins. Go figure. In my experience, I get wildly different results depending on plug-ins
sometimes. The main reason I hang onto the G5 is that Color Finesse seems to love it. Anyways...
(Nightflight Render)
Mac Pro 2.66GHz (4 GB RAM) - 69 sec in AE-CS3, 154 sec in AE-7
G5 2.5GHz Quad (4GB RAM) - 78 sec in AE-CS3, 155 sec in AE-7
Multiprocessing was enabled on both systems, so there was a big
improvement as far as Nightflight goes. Not surprisingly, the
universal code of CS3 definitely improves Intel performance more than
it helps the G5 though! But like I said. I didn't the monster
difference that Donald got, especially if one takes the faster clock
speed of the Intel system into account. Maybe if I had an Octo-Core
Mac Pro, the G5 might have gotten trounced.
James"
Donald also had a 2.66GHz Mac Pro (2GB of RAM) but his (4GB RAM) G5 was only a Dual 2GHz model (not a 2.5GHz Quad like yours) - plus he used different (much larger/longer) test files - note his times to complete were much longer.
|
|
OWC XLR8 SPECIALS!
(see full list)
= 3.5in HARD DRIVES = 1TB and 2TB HDs
2TB 7200rpm $175
= 2.5 in & SSD HDs =
SSD Drives, Notebook Hard Drives and DIY drive/case kit bundles
= MEMORY =
2009 Mac Pro kits, 2008-2006 Mac Pro FBDIMM kits, Upgrades for MacBooks/MacBook Pros/iMacs/Mac Minis!
Also ram for G5, G4 and G3 Macs from under $30!
= OPTICAL DRIVES =
Internal and External Superdrives/Blu-Ray drives.
= VIDEO CARDS/LCD/TV = GTX 285 for Mac Pro, Radeon 3870s, LCD Displays, TV tuners and more.
= SOFTWARE =
Prosoft Drive Genius 2 (under $60), Drive Genius 2 + Data Rescue 2 bundle w/big discounts.
= WIRELESS =
802.11N/g/b adapters from under $20!
= CPU UPGRADES =
G4 7448 and G3 1GHz upgrades
XLR8YourMac.com T-Shirts
Support this site!

FasterMac.net
Internet Access
Mac Model Articles
CPU Upgrade Articles
Video/Card Articles
Storage Articles
Search Mac
Drive Upgrades/Compatibility Database
Search the CPU Upgrade Database
Freq. Asked Questions
|